by Jef | Approximate reading time: 3 Minutes
Fender vs Gibson?

Fender vs Gibson?  ·  Source: Wikipedia/Gibson/Fender


Winter NAMM washed a shed load of new guitar models onto the market. With the ever increasing number of limited edition, custom shop and lower priced versions of classic Fender and Gibson designs, is there still a place for ‘standard’ varieties of American-made guitars?


The Winter NAMM 2020 release schedule was an onslaught of new guitars, reissues and boutique instruments. We saw the release of more Squier and Epiphone models made in China, Korea and Indonesia at the lower end of the market. Models made in Japan or Mexico now make up a considerable share of Fender’s guitar range. Brands like Harley Benton are pushing into the lower market segment. At the top of the market, expensive boutique and Custom Shop instruments continue to proliferate unabated.

Once upon a time you bought, say, a Stratocaster or a Les Paul and they were made in the USA. Yes, there were Custom Shop models, but the standard USA-made instruments were your first port of call. Nowadays, these types of standard models still exist, but they are getting increasingly lost in the swirling release schedules of both brands. Not to mention the burgeoning competition selling similar instruments in all price ranges. When you take into account the cheaper import models at a fraction of the cost, the standard USA-made models can seem very expensive in comparison.

Traditional vs Modern

To give you an overview of the most recent launches of both Fender and Gibson, I have listed some of the more ‘standard’ models that were announced around the Winter NAMM release this year. These are what I call the ‘middle of the road’ guitars, the standard USA-made offering by both brands. Both Gibson and Fender appear to have split these models into the more traditional and modern versions of classic instruments, so I have included both in this article for you to take into consideration.

So, is either brand going to take your money in 2020? If you were going to buy a ‘core’ USA-made guitar from either of the big brands, which way would you go?

Fender American Ultra Series

For 2020, Fender replaced the old Elite Series with the new American Ultra Series, which has plenty of modern takes on those classic Californian guitar designs we all know so well. This was possibly the biggest update for Fender this year, and actually came in quite a while before NAMM had even kicked in.

Models include the Ultra Stratocaster, Ultra HSS Stratocaster, Ultra Telecaster, Ultra Jazzmaster, Ultra Precision Bass, Ultra Jazz Bass and Ultra Jazz Bass V.




Fender American Originals

Fender also updated its American Originals series with the addition of the new ‘60s Telecaster Thinline and the ‘70s Telecaster Custom models. Again, both these guitars are made in the company’s Corona factory in California, USA. Although there are several other models to choose from in this series, I decided on including these two models as they are the company’s latest offering in this particular range.

Fender American Originals 60s Telecaster Thinline and 70s Telecaster Custom

Fender American Originals 60s Telecaster Thinline and 70s Telecaster Custom

More Information

Gibson Original and Modern Collections

Gibson had a few new offerings of its own, including the Original and Modern Collections. Both ranges come with several classic Gibson models, including Les Pauls, Specials, SGs, Explorers and more. Like the Fenders, the new Gibson ranges are American-made production run models, and not one-offs or Custom Shop models.

The following is a list of models you can expect from the new Gibson Original and Modern Collections:

  • Gibson Les Paul Classic
  • Gibson Les Paul Junior Tribute DC
  • Gibson Les Paul Special, TV Yellow
  • Gibson Les Paul Standard ’50s
  • Gibson Les Paul Standard ’60s
  • Gibson Les Paul Studio
  • Gibson Explorer
  • Gibson Firebird
  • Gibson Flying V Antique



More Information

Image Sources:
  • Fender American Ultra Series: Fender
  • Fender American Originals 60s Telecaster Thinline and 70s Telecaster Custom: Fender
  • Gibson Original Collection Les Paul Standards_50s_60s: Gibson
Fender vs Gibson?

How do you like this post?

Rating: Yours: | ø:

6 responses to “Fender and Gibson USA standard guitar models: Which would you buy?”

    Jerome says:

    It’s Suhr and Schecter for me these days. There are some Gibson’s that I would love, but I just don’t see them as good value for money when I can get a new Schecter Solo ii for about £1K

      Jef says:

      Wise words, you sound like a player on a mission to get the best bang for your buck!

      Holly Matchet says:

      Yep, I was in this same predicament less than 2 years ago. I have been a player for over 20 years but had never owned a strat. I searched for months between new and used and ultimately came to the conclusion that the Suhr was the best way to go. I mainly wanted stainless steel frets and upgrading a used guitar would probably have been about the same cost as just getting a new Suhr. I couldn’t find a Fender that had the quality and/or specs that the Suhr gave me just with their standard Classic Pro model.

      Now, about 2 years later in 2020, neither Fender or Gibson have upgraded their “American Standards” to the standards of today’s player.

      I think I will keep looking at the competition when I want something in the future.

    Cort says:

    Fender all the way.
    Better made – and at the same time, easy to repair. Also easy to modify and upgrade. Better range of sounds. Cooler – the Strat oozes history but it still looks modern. Nicer company too…
    Leo changed the world. He was as important as Henry Ford. Until Leo came along, companies like Gibson were just making the same old hollow bodies, year after year, for the price of a car. It’s amazing how few know that the Les Paul was Gibson’s answer to the success of the Telecaster.
    There’s not a model in the range that would persuade me to pay the Gibson tax.

    James Irvine says:

    I own Gibson Fender Takamine Maton and Taylor Guitars electric and Aucoustic Electric .I can tell you they are all different there is not one guitar fits all .However I bought a Gibson Les paul costom in 1987 and played only that Guitar for 22years .till I gave it to my son .And regulary .For the last 12years I’ve been trying different guitars
    The only reason I don’t play the Les paul now is that it’s too heavy on a 3 hour gig .I’m using A Takamine 178 ACK n Thinline for the type of gigs I’m doing great guitar

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *